Organ Donation: Let the Market Rule Harvard Case Solution & Analysis


The article “Organ Donation: Let the Market Rule?” basically discusses the facts about the concept of organ donation. Over here, the paper discusses the different methods of donating the organs. Moreover, the paper also explores the different ways people actually look upon the concept of organ donation which helps people live for longer durations and with health. The paper also discusses the information of affected stakeholders, ethics viewpoints, and alternative courses of action.

Facts of the Situation

There are several aspects of the article that are stated below

      In NYC, on the Long Island in the Hudson Valley, 7800 people on the list of facing organ issues where they want heart transplant, kidney transplant, etc.

      In the previous year, 682 people replaced organs.

      1.5 million dollar grant is required to start up an organ transplant hospital.

      Hundreds of patients died also because of limited organs available.

      The unsure government rules actually restrict from this activity.

Key Ethical Issue

Even though organ donation has helped people to live longer, however, it is a prohibited practice in various countries. Organ transplant does have its benefits, but in most of the cases poor people actually donate their body parts to earn some money. This is actually an ethical issue which needs to be addressed. It does save human life, but it costs too.

Additional Pieces of Secondary Information

The article basically includes diverse information related to organ donation. The added information has been presented below:

 (1)   Definition of Organ donation

The paper basically discusses and highlights the concept of organ donation; therefore, the paper also needs to understand the meaning and the definition of organ donation (Orentlicher, 2009). Organ donation is basically a process where through a surgery an organ or a tissue is removed from the body of one person (the donor) and placed it into another person who is the receipt of the organ. To donate the organ, transplantation is a necessary method which resolves the issue (Peltier, 2012). It is an issue which helps people overcomes the issues they face due to dysfunction of a specific organ in the body.

Organ Donation Let the Market Rule Case Solution

 (2)   Pros and Cons of Organ donation

(3)   Despite being an ethical issue where most countries restrict organ donation, however, it still has quite a few advantages to go with the cons of the concept.

(4)   The major advantage of organ donation is that it helps the life of the recipient. Moreover, it helps the person not only survive but it helps to live a normal life. It gives satisfaction to the donor where he feels he has served the humanity. Along with this, organ donation can help up to eight lives (Orentlicher, 2009).

(5)   The con of organ donation is that it sometimes becomes a greedy concept, where people sell their body parts to earn quick money. If the donor is a diabetes patient, it directly affects the person acquiring the body part. Nowadays, people wrongly operate body organs of poor people and sell it for extra Money.

 (6)   Organ Donations Regulations

Different countries have installed different rules for organ donation. The reason is simple; in most of the cases, countries restrict it because of the illegal use of organ donation. Poor people are forced to donate their organs and are bribed for extra money which is why it has been restricted in most parts of the world. However, some people for the sake of humanity actually do this and donate their body parts to the needy ones (Gormley, 2010).

Affected Stakeholders

Affected stakeholders are listed below:

  • Patients
  • Hospitals
  • Donor

 The stakeholders that can be considered a part of the issue as per the article are the patients who are looking for organs that can be used for their survival. Moreover, as the article presents many people still await for organs to live a sound and safe life (Peltier, 2012).  The hospitals are also the stakeholders because eventually they are the ones who help the patients and the donors for the survival. Lastly, the donor cannot take place without the person donating the organ.

 Ethics Viewpoint

In this assigned reading, the writer has not actually portrayed the negative aspect of organ donation. Over here, the writer has been of the viewpoint that organ donation has to be made possible through different methods. However, in the article nowhere is it mentioned that it is a negative thing and has some legal issues and drawbacks associated with it (Minoff, 2013).............

This is just a sample partial case solution. Please place the order on the website to order your own originally done case solution.

Other Similar Case Solutions like

Organ Donation: Let the Market Rule

Share This