PESTLE Analysis of New Jersey's Ban the Box Law Case Solution And Analysis, HBR Case Study Solution & Analysis of Harvard Case Studies

PESTLE Analysis of New Jersey's Ban the Box Law Case Solution

New Jersey has recently enacted a ban on the use of box mailers. This has caused quite a stir amongst residents of the state and those working for the mail industry. The question is, how will businesses and organisations in the state respond to this situation? Fortunately, there are several ways of finding the best possible solution to this problem.

Problem Statement

While New Jersey's "ban the box" legislation is impressive, it does not go far enough to protect the state's residents from discriminatory hiring practices. A better solution would be to adopt a multi-pronged approach to fair chance hiring, including encouraging employers to defer criminal background checks until later in the hiring process.

The most obvious implication is that Black and Hispanic men are more likely to be denied jobs because of their criminal records. This is a problem not only for individuals, but for communities of color, who have been subject to disproportionate numbers of arrests and imprisonment.

While the "ban the box" law does not ban employers from asking about criminal history, it does limit the size of the box on an employment application and the number of times it is asked. That is not to say that criminal background checks are no longer necessary; in fact, they're often required by landlords, who argue that they keep crime from infiltrating properties.

The law also includes an express preemption provision, which prohibits local governments from enacting criminal history laws in the future. These laws are aimed at protecting the state from local jurisdictions with different rules for evaluating applicants' criminal histories.

Overall, while the New Jersey "ban the box" law is an important first step, further research is needed to assess its impact on employment. In addition, more policymakers and lawmakers should support best practices for employers and applicants alike.

Case Study Solution

Ban the Box is a national movement to ban employers from asking applicants about their criminal history. It is aimed at eliminating the stigma associated with having a criminal record. Many states and cities have adopted ban the box laws.

The New Jersey ban the box law will be effective in less than a month. Senate Bill 3306 was signed into law by Governor Chris Christie on December 20, 2017. This ban the box law prevents employers from using online applications that require the disclosure of an applicant's criminal history.

Employers have several options when deciding how to apply the new law. Some choose to rely on individualized assessment of the applicant's criminal history, while others delay the background check until after the first interview.

The best practice is to remove prior conviction questions from employment applications. Although the law does not specifically prohibit such language, the EEOC views these questions with suspicion. If the use of these criminal background words is viewed as discriminatory, a company could face costly penalties.

Before implementing a "Ban the Box" policy, an employer should understand the requirements of the law. As the law becomes more widely enforced, employers may need to adjust their hiring practices.

Employers should not hesitate to contact legal counsel when asking questions about the law. In addition to the New Jersey ban the box law, employers should also understand the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act's adverse action provisions.

Porters Five Forces

"Ban the Box" law is a local ordinance in Newark. This law took effect in November 2012. The law is modeled after similar laws in California and Massachusetts, as well as a number of other states. These laws were meant to help an estimated 70 million ex-offenders find work.

Although the aforementioned ban the box law is not applicable to private companies, the law still applies to public sector employers, like hospitals and school districts. As with any local or state law, there are some exclusions, such as emergency management, corrections, and homeland security. A good rule of thumb is to consult legal counsel before you ask about the laws' finer points. Those who break the law could face up to $500 in penalties, with the possibility of a bigger one for a second or third violation.

Several companies have reached a settlement with the State. Some of the more notable include FedEx Corporation, which provides two shipping services; and UPS, the world's largest express transportation company. In the sphere of logistics, FedEx Ground is the second-largest small package ground delivery service provider.

While the New Jersey Opportunity to Compete Act is certainly the most high-profile, it is just the latest in a long line of "Ban the Box" laws. If you're a small business owner in New Jersey, or are considering becoming one, you'll want to do your due diligence before you take your business to the next level.

PESTLE Analysis

There are many factors to consider when conducting a PESTLE analysis of New Jersey's ban the box law. These include the legal, technological, environmental, and social. Identifying these factors and using them to your advantage can lead to a number of successes, including boosting sales.

Legal factors affect your business as a direct result of governmental laws and regulations. These could be the local or state level and may differ from one jurisdiction to the next. You'll also need to pay attention to liability and taxation laws in each jurisdiction.

The legal or technical factors affecting your business should be the focus of your attention. If you're in the market for a new employee, you'll want to ensure that they have the necessary qualifications. A cursory review of any interview guide or hiring policy is a good start.

The most important element to remember is that ban the box does not apply to jobs where a criminal history background check is required. This is not to say that there are no exceptions to the rule, just that the law will not apply to these positions.

Technological and environmental factors will also impact your business. For example, in the construction industry, a scarcity of timber can be a big problem. However, there are several ways to solve this issue.

One example is to make use of recyclable materials in your construction project. Another is to show corporate social responsibility by engaging in philanthropic activities.

Financial Analysis

The Opportunity To Compete Act or "Ban the Box" law is a new legislation that was signed into law by Governor Chris Christie on August 11, 2014. It will go into effect in less than a month.

This legislation is intended to help people with criminal backgrounds find employment. In some cases, unemployment leads to a cycle of incarceration and recidivism.

While it is a federal law, the legislation will not affect local municipalities, chain businesses, or franchises. However, if you are in one of these areas, you will need to adjust your hiring practices.

Several cities and counties have already adopted a ban the box policy. In fact, more than 100 jurisdictions have taken steps in recent years. These laws vary in their implementation, but generally restrict employers from asking about criminal histories on job applications.

Many companies that operate outside of New Jersey are affected by the Ban the Box legislation. If you are an employer in these areas, you may be subject to fines for violations. Depending on the nature of the violation, you could receive a $500 or $1,000 civil penalty.

Fortunately, the Opportunity to Compete Act supersedes any municipal or county ordinance. For this reason, New Jersey businesses will be in compliance. As a matter of fact, the law will even override any municipal or county ordinance that already prohibits employers from requiring applicants to disclose criminal records before being hired.

Recommendations

With the New Jersey Opportunity to Compete Act taking effect in less than a month, it's important for employers to understand the law and the impact that it will have on their hiring practices. The Opportunity to Compete Act, also known as "Ban the Box", reduces the barriers to employment for people with criminal records. It's not enough to adopt a fair chance hiring policy; employers need to implement it properly.

Ban the Box laws require postponing a criminal history inquiry until after an applicant has been given a conditional offer of employment. This deferral ensures that an employer will consider an applicant's skills and qualifications first. But if an employer chooses not to hire an applicant based on their criminal background, they can face penalties.

Under federal law, an employer has five days to make an adverse action notice. If an employer fails to comply, the Department of Labor and Workforce Development can issue a Notice of Violation. In addition, the employer may be required to pay a $1,000 civil penalty for the first violation and $5,000 for subsequent violations.

Ban the Box policies have been adopted by more than 100 municipalities/counties. However, further research is needed to fully assess their effects on society.

Although many states have enacted ban the box policies in recent years, more needs to be done. States should adopt a comprehensive suite of fair chance hiring policies, ensuring that everyone has equitable access to the labor market.

This is just a sample partial case solution. Please place the order on the website to order your own originally done case solution.

PESTLE Analysis of New Jersey’s Ban the Box Law Harvard Case Solution & Analysis